Review: THE ENEMY: DETROIT 1954 by Sara Holbrook

From her “Chicks Up Front” days to a recent piece on how one of her poems was botched by a Texas standardized test, Sara Holbrook has always been in the right place, saying what needs to be said. It’s no surprise that her first novel for young readers, The Enemy: Detroit 1954, is perfectly in sync with our troubled times.

Holbrook’s main character Marjorie Campbell is twelve years old as the atrocities of World War II are still etched in the minds of Americans, although children of her age have no direct memories of them. Many are also preoccupied with the Cold War fears of creeping Communism. For Marjorie and other children, these perceptions are playing out for real in their Detroit neighborhood when books deemed subversive (1984, The Grapes of Wrath) are removed from library shelves, and newcomers are treated with suspicion. When Marjorie is assigned to share a desk with the just-arrived Inga, she is torn between her instinct to be friendly and her classmates’ intentions to be unwelcoming.

Holbrook respects her readers by presenting the complexity of Marjorie’s situation. Members of her family and community have been directly affected by the war, and they harbor negative attitudes toward Germans and DPs (displaced persons). Others are concerned with over-reaching attempts to limit freedoms in the name of safeguarding against Communism. Marjorie takes it all in, and then relies on her heart to make decisions about how she will navigate her neighborhood and her world.

Marjorie’s voice in The Enemy is charmingly innocent, smart, and vulnerable. Here is her description of one of the local librarians: “Mrs. Pearson has her arms crossed tightly, the way she always does. Crossed arms are as natural to her as breathing. It makes me wonder how she opens a car door or flushes a toilet. I imagine she was born with her arms crossed, telling the doctor to keep it down as soon as she opened her eyes.” Sara Holbrook definitely knows how kids think and speak.

Today’s middle school and high school students are well aware of what is going on around them. They see the protests and hear the inflammatory rhetoric. Reading The Enemy: Detroit 1954 in a time when our government is focused on creating a classes of “others” through harsh characterizations and targeted immigration policies will give adolescents a context for processing their own roles in today’s swirling events, and considering whether “the enemy” is outsiders or dark impulses closer to home.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

What’s Not Wrong with All These Writing Conferences

idea-605766_1280For the past couple of years, I’ve worked in a college writing center.  I really like this job.  Students come to me with their papers, and we confer about their writing.  They think we’re working on the assignments, but my true goal is helping them develop as writers.  Since my retirement from full-time teaching, I’ve plied my trade in a variety of education-related contexts, but these writing center conferences just might be the most gratifying.  Why?

The least important reason is the most selfish.  There is no advance preparation, and there is no work to take home.  I arrive fresh, and I depart unburdened.  This leaves time and energy for my other pursuits.

The other reasons why I like all these writing conferences may be of interest to other writing teachers.

There is no wasted energy in a writing conference.  Sometimes in a class I feel like my instruction is shooting off sparks that don’t really ignite anything.  Maybe some students have other pressing issues on their minds.  Maybe I’m teaching some mandated content that I don’t really believe in, and the students can tell.  Maybe my approach is reaching some students but falling short with others.  With one-to-one conferences, none of that is a factor.  If my approach isn’t working, I know immediately and switch to another path.  The student and I are focused, 100% productive, and locked on to a mission.  The student sets the conference agenda, and my role is help him discover how to get un-stuck, apply a rhetorical or mechanical concept, or think about writing in new ways.  Everything we say and do together in our writing conference is directly related to developing a specific piece of writing and to helping him grow in confidence and competence as a writer.

One-to-one instruction provides opportunity for personal connection.  Because conferring is individualized, it’s more conversational than whole-class instruction.  As I talk with students, they can usually tell I’m interested in their writing and thinking, and I truly care about helping them.  When that realization kicks in, we move to a higher plane of transaction in our communication.  Their writer brains become more energized, and their writer muscles flex more deliberately.  Each conferring session ends with better writing, a stronger writer, and exchanges of gratitude.  They thank me for my help, and I thank them for the opportunity to work with them, and I encourage them to return.

Some writing problems are best solved individually.  Understanding writing as a process is a revelation for some students.  My favorite tutoring sessions are those where a student doesn’t how to begin.  She may have some ideas or understanding of content but not quite see how to develop that material into an organized multi-paragraph format.  I usually ask a student like this to just talk about what she wants to say while I take some notes.  Then I present her own words to her in a rough outline form.  Aha!  Suddenly those scattered thoughts look a lot better when they have some structure imposed on them.  Then we talk about how the human mind can think up cool stuff, but it doesn’t arrive in an orderly manner.  The writer’s job is to arrange those cool ideas so that they can be easily digested by a reader.  That progression from scattered thoughts to somewhat organized ideas to a well-reasoned, reader-friendly argument is a process that students will eventually learn to trust.

When students are under time pressure, they may want to generate an entire paper all at the same time without understanding that it must be built and developed rather than just flung down in one splash.  These writers try to start with the introduction’s first sentence, jam right through to the conclusion, print it out, and hand that sucker in.  Writing just doesn’t work that way!  No wonder they are stuck!   I explain that having a general direction is a good idea, but it might actually be most useful to write the body paragraphs first and then craft an introduction and conclusion for that material.  Starting with what they understand best is usually more productive than trying to start with some vague notion of an attention-grabber in an introduction for material that doesn’t exist.

Some students have an assignment sheet but are paralyzed by the all of the requirements and expectations:  underline topic sentences, mark details in the margin, APA style, etc.  Again, these students may try to “efficiently” write an essay while simultaneously inserting all of these non-rhetorical elements.  I tell these writers they are trying to paint the house before it’s built.  They need to go through the discovery and development phases of the process.  There are no shortcuts.


Discussions about these issues rarely happen in whole-class settings for a variety of reason.  Even when these topics are discussed in class, individual students may not see them as personally relevant, even if they are.  But when these conversations about writing happen in a one-to-one conference, the learning is focused, individualized, and more personally gratifying.

These benefits are real, but I wonder if they transfer to settings beyond college writing centers.  Do they have relevance for classroom teachers who hold writing conferences with their students?  Thanks for your feedback.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , | 4 Comments

Seven More Nonfiction Picture Books for Your Consideration

This is a strong batch of books–no duds here.  Along with some of the books in last month’s installment of reviews, many of these titles can become part of a collection featuring culturally diverse personalities and topics.

Frederick Douglass: The Lion Who Wrote HistoryFrederick Douglass: The Lion Who Wrote History by Walter Dean Myers

Readers of this new picture book biography of Frederick Douglass will easily come away with important understandings about slavery, the connection between education and freedom, and the role of Frederick Douglass in obtaining both emancipation for slaves and suffrage for women. Masterfully told by the late Walter Dean Myers, the Douglass who emerges from these pages is tough, brave, smart, and passionate—a role model for our times. The dramatic Floyd Cooper illustrations effectively present the face of a thinking man set against historically significant backdrops. Presenting slavery with both accuracy and sensitivity to young readers is a challenge for picture book creators, and Frederick Douglass: The Lion Who Wrote History meets the challenge with text and images that are both powerful and palatable. This life of Frederick Douglass emphasizes how one voice can change history, a lesson for every American home, classroom, and library.

The Youngest Marcher: The Story of Audrey Faye Hendricks, a Young Civil Rights ActivistThe Youngest Marcher: The Story of Audrey Faye Hendricks, a Young Civil Rights Activist by Cynthia Levinson

In May, 1963, more than three thousand children were jailed in Birmingham, Alabama after peacefully protesting the city’s segregation policies. Audrey Faye Hendricks, the youngest of those children, spent a week in jail before all the cells were filled, the children were released, and some of those segregation policies began to change. Audrey narrates her story in an uplifting tone that is mostly cheerful but also conveys her indignance at being denied equality with white children, and her fear and discomfort while in jail. The Youngest Marcher will pair well with Malala: Activist for Girls’ Education by Raphaële Frier to demonstrate how even the youngest members of a society sometimes play important, courageous roles in the quests for freedom and justice.

Ticktock Banneker's ClockTicktock Banneker’s Clock by Shana Keller

Benjamin Banneker, a young colonial-era farmer, is interested in how things work. When a friend loans him a pocket watch, Benjamin is fascinated and decides to use it as a model to build a bigger clock. Working with math and the concept of scale, Benjamin uses his troubleshooting and problem-solving skills to successfully craft a mantle clock out of surprising materials. Although David C. Gardner’s illustrations reveal that Benjamin is of African descent, that fact is not a major element in Shana Keller’s narrative. The back matter explains that even though Banneker was born free he was denied access to most educational opportunities because of his race. Ticktock Banneker’s Clock will appeal to young inventors, and shows math’s real-world relevance. The historical context also provides worthwhile aspects for consideration and discussion as we are presented with a true story of an African-American who applied his ingenuity to challenges in a time filled with obstacles.

Martin's Dream DayMartin’s Dream Day by Kitty Kelley

I’ll admit to being a little skeptical about approaching a Martin Luther King picture book authored by celebrity biographer Kitty Kelley. Martin’s Dream Day, however, is an excellent addition to a bookshelf devoted to King, America’s struggle with civil rights, and the 1963 March on Washington where King delivered his “I Have a Dream” speech. In addition to clear, accessible text, the illustrations in Martin’s Dream Day are historic photographs taken by the late photojournalist Stanley Tretick.

My favorite aspect of presenting history to young people is illuminating how events and people connect. Nothing ever happens in isolation. This picture book provides concise background for the civil rights movement, King’s involvement, and the march itself. In addition, Martin’s Dream Day provides clear connective tissue not only to those topics, but also to the nation’s capital, President John F. Kennedy, Congressman John Lewis, and how a bill becomes law.

AbrahamAbraham by Frank Keating

Abraham, written by former Oklahoma governor Frank Keating, is a worthwhile addition to collections. Told in first person from Lincoln’s point of view, the narrative concentrates on Lincoln’s early life but also covers his career up to the end of the Civil War. As Lincoln tells about formative experiences, primarily hard work and a passion for reading, the text effectively integrates quotes from Lincoln’s own writings. (These passages can be used as models to show students how to incorporate quotes into their own sentences.) Mike Wimmer’s illustrations of young Lincoln intriguingly show him as younger versions of the person we know from the familiar photographs taken later in life. Some of the vocabulary toward the end (emblazoned, unfettered) may be challenging for elementary readers to decode on their own, but the captivating artwork and engaging perspective successfully convey an appealing Abraham Lincoln.

Malala: Activist for Girls' EducationMalala: Activist for Girls’ Education by Raphaële Frier

Consider the challenge of conveying Malala Yousafzai’s story in a way that is appropriate for children: Malala’s courage and convictions arose from a context of political and personal violence. Malala: Activist for Girls’ Education masterfully navigates this territory. Author Raphaële Frier does not shy away from the Taliban’s brutality, including the shooting of Malala on a school bus, but she first establishes Malala’s passion for education, beliefs in the rights of girls, and her family’s role in providing schooling for Pakistani children. The illustrations from Aurélia Fronty present Malala and other individuals in a more expressionistic manner, reminiscent of muralists. The bright artwork is not gruesome or graphic on the pages conveying violent episodes, although it is dramatic. Young readers will come away from the main text with an understanding of how one person can make a difference, as well as the obstacles to freedom faced by some children, especially girls, in other cultures. The back matter presents photographs of Malala, numerous quotes from her, and background material relevant to understanding her life, work, and culture.

One Proud PennyOne Proud Penny by Randy Siegel
A plain 1983-vintage penny tells its story with pride. Since its minting in Philadelphia, this penny has been spent, saved, lost, and found many times in its travels around the country. No matter what happens, this penny is proud to do its job, even though 250 billion other pennies are out there. Mixing whimsical, engaging art with real images of pennies, One Proud Penny blends scientific and historical facts about pennies with more imaginative considerations about the role of pennies in our lives and economy. One Proud Penny will build on kids’ inherent curiosity about coins and money.


These reviews appeared elsewhere in slightly different form.

Which of these sound most promising for your young readers?

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Six Nonfiction Picture Books for Young Readers

Each month in 2017, I’m planning to offer a round-up of recent nonfiction picture books with the hope that it will help parents and educators at all levels sort through and pick titles that are the best choices for their homes, classrooms, and libraries.

The first three books reviewed in this installment are excellent choices for Black History Month.

Preaching to the ChickensPreaching to the Chickens by Jabari Asim

Although John Lewis became an extraordinarily important civil rights leader, Jabari Asim and E. B. Lewis give us the child who became that leader. Young John had to work hard on an Alabama farm, but the work he especially liked was caring for the chickens. He also liked going to church. Eventually John began sharing the spiritual lessons learned from his mother and his church with those chickens, and they seemed to understand his messages. Through this appealing depiction of a child finding ways to be positive in a world filled with challenges, readers will easily see foreshadowing of John Lewis’s later work with larger “flocks.”

Beyond being engaging as a nonfiction picture book narrative, Asim’s rich text can also provide students with examples of description, sensory images, details, and dialogue. The watercolors of E. B. Lewis, as in his other work in Jacqueline Woodson’s picture books, strike a dramatic balance between impressionism and realism.

Preaching to the Chickens is one of the finest nonfiction picture books of the past year.

The Legendary Miss Lena HorneThe Legendary Miss Lena Horne by Carole Boston Weatherford

Lena Horne would turn 100 this year, and The Legendary Miss Lena Horne is a worthy tribute to this icon. Although Horne may be largely unknown to today’s youngest readers, author Carole Boston Weatherford provides an engaging narrative for Horne’s life and career that touches on the Harlem Renaissance, Jim Crow South, prejudice on stage and screen, the civil rights movement, and ends with a nod to how “black stars now gleam on red carpets and reap box-office gold.” The text is accompanied by Elizabeth Zunon’s bright illustrations that effectively convey both the despair and glamour of Lena Horne. Rarely does a picture book biography so brilliantly capture an important life as well as a century of important periods in American history.

Muhammad Ali: A Champion Is BornMuhammad Ali: A Champion Is Born by Gene Barretta

Muhammad Ali: A Champion is Born is an excellent picture book introduction for young readers to the legend of The Greatest. After an introductory note explaining that Cassius Clay and Muhammad Ali are the same person, the opening pages show the major moments from Ali’s boxing career and capture his charisma through his words. The illustrations are accurate but not overly graphic. Then the narrative moves back to an episode from Ali’s childhood. When his new bike is stolen, young Cassius appeals to a police officer for help, and the officer introduces him to the sport of boxing. From there, Ali’s life and career are conveyed with attention to both his athleticism and activism. The illustrations are bright and cartoon-like as they portray first a child and then a man who became the most well-known person on the planet. Ali’s life serves as a lesson that no matter what bad things might happen—a stolen bike, racial or religious persecution—we can always choose to respond with positivity.

Where Are the Words?Where Are the Words? by Jodi McKay

A little period feels like writing a story but doesn’t have words. With the help of its friends—other punctuation marks and some (low-tech) writing supplies–words galore come along. Although a little muddled in the middle, Where Are the Words? features many good ideas about writing, including how punctuation can help shape ideas, how creativity can be sparked just by putting things side by side, and how supportive friends can sometimes provide inspiration when writers are stuck.

For those who use picture books in middle and secondary grades, Where Are the Words? has humor, sophisticated ideas, and clever illustrations and graphics that make it a worthwhile addition to upper-level classroom collections in addition to its obvious appeal for elementary classrooms and libraries.

Who Is Bruce Springsteen?Who Is Bruce Springsteen? by Stephanie Sabol

This worthwhile addition to the venerable “Who Is?” series aimed at upper elementary-age readers covers the important aspects of Bruce Springsteen’s life and career. I can easily imagine young readers knowing about Springsteen from their parents and picking up this book to understand more about him, or to learn about the life of a rock star. Filled with illustrations that are eerily accurate, Bruce’s journey is explained in a kid-friendly approach that emphasizes how his growth as a writer mirrored his development as an artist. Supplemental materials include side-by-side timelines of Bruce’s life and important world events, as well as page-length explanations of relevant concepts such as “blue collar,” “Elvis Presley,” and “September 11.”

It's a Sunny Life: An Adventure Fit for Rain or ShineIt’s a Sunny Life: An Adventure Fit for Rain or Shine by Gary Lezak

The story here is thin as “cool TV weather man” Gary decides that he should take his newly adopted puppy Sunny on a mountain-climbing adventure with his other dogs as a bonding activity. The weather turns bad and Sunny quickly becomes lost. Astonishingly, a helper dog named Jamie appears to point Sunny back in the right direction based on Sunny’s “choice” to leave tracks in the snow. Just as astonishingly, Jamie cannot be located when Gary returns to the cave with Sunny and the other dogs.

Author Gary Lezak is a Kansas City television meteorologist. It’s a Sunny Life may be of interest to those who see him on a regular basis, but there isn’t much in the book in terms of character or plot. Young readers fascinated by weather might hang in there with Lezak’s adventure story, and the eight pages of weather terms and facts found in the back material can also provide them with insights into weather phenomena.

I’m eager to know how the kids in your world respond to these books!

As always, thanks for reading.

These reviews appeared on Goodreads in slightly different form.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Do Whatever You Want

Before launching this blog six years ago, I wrote posts for a variety of online forums.  From time to time, I re-post them here if they still seem relevant.  This one originally appeared in slightly different form on English Companion.

cover-artworkI care deeply about what goes on in my class and with my students. I will do pretty much anything to reach, teach, motivate, accommodate, develop, and inspire the hundred-plus students that I am so fortunate to have assigned to me each year. I care about what they learn, how they learn, and my role in their development as writers, readers, thinkers, and citizens. My personal goal is for every one of them to have a quality literacy experience in my class each day, and most days I feel like my goal is achieved.

But up and down the halls of my school are other classrooms with other students and other teachers. While I wish them all well in a more abstract sense—hoping that they too are having quality literacy experiences—I’m growing weary of having those students and teachers being grafted on to my work load.

Here is what I mean. A growing trend toward mandated collaboration and professional learning communities is playing out in our schools resulting in a kind of paralysis among too many teachers who seem unable to make decisions or move forward unless every other teacher is doing pretty much the same thing at the same time. If that works for them, hallelujah, but it doesn’t work for me.

I believe in the following principles regarding teacher autonomy:

• Teachers should be relatively independent beings who know how to collaborate when it best serves the needs of their students.

• Classrooms are highly contextual. What works for one teacher and one set of students should not automatically be presumed to be “best practice” for any other teacher or class. Heck, it might not even work for that teacher on a different day or in a different class!

• Emerson was right when he said, “A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds.” Consistency between teachers has the possibility of being “worst practice” if teachers apply inappropriate strategies and methodologies, even if those strategies and methodologies are consistent and successful with other teachers. When all classes and students are consistent, then and only then will teacher consistency make any sense.

So, when I’m ordered to participate in a collaboration session, I am sometimes reluctant to engage in it. I respect each of my colleagues, but I see teachers who do not know how to plan on their own, teachers who try very hard not to change a single thing from last year’s lesson plans, and teachers who believe that their way of doing things is the only valid way. What do my students gain from my collaboration with those colleagues?

If their approaches are working for their students, what’s the problem? If their approaches are not working for their students, is it my responsibility to take time and energy from my own classes in order to make their classes better? My experience, unfortunately, shows me that forced collaboration is more likely to result in some kind of incoherent least-common-denominator mishmash, usually designed to satisfy an obsession with data or standardized assessments.

I don’t want to seem like an iconoclastic ogre. I value collaboration when it benefits my students and my teaching. I participate in some form of collaboration almost every day through an ever-growing network of teachers whose opinions, expertise, and experience I have found to be sound, wise, and valuable. Some of those teachers are on-site; some are across town; some are online. It is also my great honor to be asked from time to time to consult with individual teachers, schools, and districts to help them with their classroom practices and writing programs. In these instances, collaboration is authentic, voluntary, and tends to be focused on pragmatic problem-solving.

So, Wise Ones of the Blogosphere, please help me find the balance. When is collaboration healthy? When is it unhealthy? And is it OK to care more about my own classes than about what is happening down the hall? I’m interested in responses from teachers in all career stages. Thanks for your replies.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Baseball Books for the 2017 Off-Season: Cubs-Kinsella Edition

617305340-e1477191679888For this sixth annual round-up of baseball books I’ve read in the past year, I’m thinking about some things that are different this time.  One of them is sad; one of them is joyous.

Let’s start with the joyous.

The Chicago Cubs won the World Series!

How awesome is that?!?  The team provided a great season, great stories, great personalities, a great World Series, a great game seven, and a great celebration.  Those readers in the Chicago area know that every day we see many, many people decked out in Cubs championship gear.  We see W flags everywhere.  The 2016 Chicago Cubs will forever be heroes no matter where they go or where their fans may roam.

The sadder note involves the passing of two of my favorite baseball writers:  Gene Fehler and W. P. Kinsella.  These two gentlemen were instrumental in forming my understanding of how baseball and literature can merge.  Fehler’s Center Field Grasses is still the best book of baseball poetry I’ve ever read.  When I first blogged about baseball books in 2011, here is what I said about Center Field Grasses:  “Page after page of perfect baseball poems. If you only read one book from this list, it should probably be this one.”  I was honored when Gene Fehler left a nice comment on my About page.

W. P. Kinsella was the author of many fine baseball books, including Shoeless Joe and The Iowa Baseball Confederacy.  I was honored to meet him a couple of times.  The first was at a book store when he came to Chicago to promote Box Socials.  I was there a little early, standing near the front of the store looking at magazines.  A book store employee was nearby asking people who came in the door, “Are you here for the signing?” and directing those interested toward the back of the store.  When Kinsella arrived, bushy hair flying and glasses askew, she didn’t know it was him and asked, “Are you here for the signing?”  Kinsella answered in a big voice, “I am the signing!”

Gail Borden Library in Elgin, Illinois also hosted Kinsella for a talk and signing one afternoon.  Again, I was early, and I had the chance to visit with him one on one.  I don’t remember the exact context, but he gave me a piece of writing advice.  He said that whenever he was stuck, he would set aside his work and take out a little piece of paper and write a little poem about what he was really trying to say.

That day I also told Kinsella a Shoeless Joe-related story.  When I taught that book to a group of AP seniors, a couple of them came up with the idea to call Veda Ponikvar.  Veda Ponikvar was the Minnesota journalist who wrote Moonlight Graham’s obituary.  When W. P. Kinsella came to Minnesota to learn more about Moonlight Graham’s life, her beautiful tribute became an important thread in his most famous novel, and Veda Ponikvar is mentioned by name in Shoeless Joe.  When my students called Ms. Ponikvar she told them that when Kinsella came to town he was accompanied by … J. D. Salinger, also a character in Shoeless Joe.  After talking to Veda Ponikvar, my students couldn’t wait to call me at home at night to tell about their conversation.  I was fascinated that my students called up a character in a novel who told them a story about the author that was likely just as fictional as the novel.  Anyway, I told Kinsella all this that day in Elgin, and he just shook his shaggy head without responding to any of it.

Kinsella also wrote the excellent short story “The Last Pennant Before Armageddon,” in which God tells the crusty old manager of the Chicago Cubs in a dream that the Cubs can win the National League pennant but the world will end the next day, and it’s the manager’s choice.  This story can be found in Kinsella’s short story collection The Thrill of the Grass.

I’m sorry there will not be more baseball fiction from W. P. Kinsella.  His life ended with a doctor’s assistance on September, 16, 2016, the day after the Cubs clinched the National League Central title and a month before the Cubs claimed the National League pennant.

Let’s move on to the books.  This year I will share one novel, two nonfiction titles, and four picture books.  It seems only fitting to lead off with a book involving the Chicago Cubs.

Best Seat in the House: Diary of a Wrigley Field UsherBest Seat in the House: Diary of a Wrigley Field Usher by Bruce Bohrer

Bruce Bohrer is the kind of usher who puts the “friendly” in The Friendly Confines, Wrigley Field’s nickname. The subtitle—“Diary of a Wrigley Field Usher”—tells you how this book is organized. Bohrer simply jotted down his impressions of the Cubs games he worked from 2003-2011. Nothing fancy here. My favorite parts were Bohrer’s descriptions of the signs, sights, and shirts he witnessed. Wrigley Field is not like any other place on Earth, and Bruce Bohrer captures its charm. As the team, park, and neighborhood continue to evolve, Bohrer’s remembrances may become even more important and poignant.

The Baseball Whisperer: A Small-Town Coach Who Shaped Big League DreamsThe Baseball Whisperer: A Small-Town Coach Who Shaped Big League Dreams by Michael Tackett

The Baseball Whisperer is Michael Tackett’s look inside the Clarinda A’s, a semipro team situated in a small Iowa town that has produced more than thirty major-league players, including one Hall-of-Famer, Ozzie Smith. Merle Eberly was the coach and manager of the A’s for decades, but it was a family endeavor more than the work of one man, and that family is the book’s focus.

The Clarinda A’s were not a glamorous team in terms of fancy trappings and state of the art equipment, but they won consistently and, more importantly, fostered a sense of community among the players, and between the team and the town. It’s easy to admire the small town that embraces the A’s players and takes them into their homes, as well as the way Eberly used baseball to shape college players into men of character.

Tackett writes lovingly about every aspect of the Clarinda A’s, but in some places the long quotes make his book seem more like an unedited scrapbook than a narrative, although it always finds its way back to the heart of the story. If you want a nice read about people with an admirable attitude toward baseball, The Baseball Whisperer is worth your time.

The Might Have BeenThe Might Have Been by Joseph M. Schuster

Edward Everett Yates is a baseball player. That’s all he’s ever been. Players like Edward Everett will do whatever it takes to stay in the game and avoid “the World” of a mundane job and family obligations. Sometimes that involves making conscious decisions, but fate also has a way of intervening, like the freak injury that leaves Edward Everett with Moonlight Graham-like career statistics. But there is always a story behind the metrics, and that stats vs. story conflict is important in The Might Have Been. Various characters value one more than the other, resulting in the decisions and consequences at the heart of Joseph M. Schuster’s novel.

I admire how Schuster unfolds the in-game scenes. Baseball is a game where minute details control larger outcomes, and Schuster masterfully illuminates the drama in those details, even though they last only an instant. Schuster also gives us the wider scope of the game, as we see Edward Everett navigating the nuances of the game on and off the field, controlling them to whatever extent he can, all while floundering in his non-baseball relationships. Devotion to something—baseball, family, logic—means that other things will be less important. The Might Have Been is about what we choose to put at the center of our lives.

The Kid from Diamond Street: The Extraordinary Story of Baseball Legend Edith HoughtonThe Kid from Diamond Street: The Extraordinary Story of Baseball Legend Edith Houghton by Audrey Vernick

With The Kid from Diamond Street, Audrey Vernick and Steven Salerno bring us another excellent nonfiction baseball picture book.

Edith Houghton, the kid from Diamond Street in Philadelphia, liked to say, “I guess I was born with a baseball in my hand.” By the time she was ten years old, Edith was the starting shortstop for the 1922 Philadelphia Bobbies, a professional women’s baseball team. As a member of the Bobbies, she barnstormed across America and toured Japan.

I’m extremely glad that Audrey Vernick continues to unearth these historic baseball treasures. Not only does she preserve little known niches of baseball history, but Vernick finds the angles most likely to captivate young readers. Steven Salerno’s artwork evokes the 1920s with caricatures just this side of being cartoons and scenes colored in tones similar to postcards of that era.

Can you tell I like everything about this book?

A Ticket to the Pennant: A Tale of Baseball in SeattleA Ticket to the Pennant: A Tale of Baseball in Seattle by Mark Holtzen

Huey is on the way to a championship game featuring his beloved Seattle Rainiers–a minor league team in the 1950s–but he can’t find his ticket! So, he revisits everywhere he has been lately to see if he can recover the missing ticket. After he finds his ticket in a surprising place, he arrives at the game just in time to witness a dramatic finish.

The story here is a little thin, but it gives author Mark Holtzen the opportunity to pay homage to various Seattle landmarks and family businesses, as well as insights into minor league play from several decades ago. Illustrator John Skewes is a former Disney artist, and his characters are both expressive and fun to look at.

The love of baseball definitely comes through here, and those in the Seattle area will especially enjoy this tale.

Baseball Saved UsBaseball Saved Us by Ken Mochizuki

I’m forever amazed at the number of poignant stories swirling around the great game of baseball. Has any other game ever provided as many life lessons?

Baseball Saved Us involves a Japanese-American boy whose family is part of the internment camp program during World War II. As he becomes aware of the hatred aimed at him and his race, he channels his emotions into baseball.

This picture book is an excellent choice for helping young readers better understand many topics and issues: prejudice, World War II, governmental mistakes, emotional self-control, etc. Baseball Saved Us would work well for a read-aloud, book group discussion, or stand-alone text.

The William Hoy Story: How a Deaf Baseball Player Changed the GameThe William Hoy Story: How a Deaf Baseball Player Changed the Game by Nancy Churnin

Here is yet another excellent nonfiction picture book about one of baseball’s lesser-known figures. William Hoy was a deaf major-league player from the turn of the last century who was known for his strong, accurate outfield throws and his prowess in stealing bases.

With bright colors and easy-to-discern facial expressions, The William Hoy Story effectively conveys a range of emotions, as well as important messages about perseverance and physical differences.

For more baseball book reviews, search “baseball” on this blog.

Please let me know your recommendations of other baseball books!  Thanks for reading.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

The Trouble with Peer Editing (and Some Ways to Fix It)


A student came to the writing center upset and confused by the feedback from a peer editing session. Please don’t let this happen.

I learned the hard way about some of the pitfalls involved in inviting students to perform peer-review of each other’s writing. It seems like such a good idea. Weak writers can learn from their peers who are stronger writers. Talking to each other about writing seems like a good way to spend some student-centered class time. Students can speak to each other about writing-related issues in their own language, which might be more accessible than how I say things. Young writers can garner individual attention for their writing more efficiently than if their teacher is the sole source of feedback.

So why does peer editing tend to be so ineffective? Why does it frequently cause more problems than it solves while not making much difference in students’ writing ability? I think it comes down to this: Young writers are motivated by feedback that it is individualized, relevant, and supportive, and peer review rarely synergizes those three elements and sometimes doesn’t achieve any of them.


Peer review of writing operates on a problematic paradox. Writing is personal while peer review is social. When we require students to take their personal words based on their personal ideas and personal experiences and subject them to “constructive criticism” from others, we’re asking for trouble. The social constructs in a classroom are complex, especially in middle school and high school. Putting a student’s writing out there as the agenda for social transactions is emotionally dangerous. From a learning perspective, stronger students don’t gain much from their weaker peers. When weaker writers are paired with other weak writers, we have the blind leading the blind. Either way, the weaker writers usually know how they are being pigeonholed, which does little for the confidence necessary in developing writers.

Peer editing usually takes one of two forms. Sometimes students are paired up or divided into small groups, and then they read each other’s papers with the expectation that they will provide comments or corrections. Another format frequently used is a writer-of-the-day format where one student’s writing is read by a larger group of peers who then discusses it while the writer listens and presumably learns from the classmates’ comments.

To my chagrin, I’ve lived through horrific examples of each of these. Too many times I’ve seen students emerge from those pass-around sessions with a few misspelled words circled and a vague “Good job” scribbled across the top. Too often these kinds of sessions default to grammar and other mechanical issues that are easy to define in terms of correctness. Larger issues of clarity, organization, development, and appeal are more difficult for students to articulate to one another so they receive little attention. Sometimes students think it’s OK to use this situation to score points against those not in their social group or with less social capital. Not much learning about writing happens from any of that.

I’ve also seen critique sessions with larger groups dominated by a student wearing a mental beret who, deeming herself The Best Writer in the Class, rips into other students’ writing with withering commentary. These sessions require immediate interventions and some follow-up one-on-one talks with the students involved. Even when the verbal comments are more appropriate, the student whose work is under consideration is frequently so uncomfortable that she doesn’t learn very much.

Despite these difficulties, peer editing is worthwhile, and it can work!

Here are three things I’ve learned about peer editing that teachers can roll out easily and use immediately.

Replace criticisms with suggesticisms. After a negative class workshop session like the one described above, I made up a new word.

Suggesticism (noun): A criticism paired with a suggestion.

I announced that I was imposing a new rule. Henceforth, criticism of other students’ writing would be replaced by suggesticisms. We would no longer allow a criticism without an accompanying suggestion.

I explained that a criticism might sound like this: “The metaphor in your third line—‘green as Mountain Dew puke’—is gross and offensive.” A suggesticism, however, works like this: “The metaphor in your third line—‘green as Mountain Dew puke’—is gross and offensive. Would you consider trying ‘green as a lime rind’ instead?”

This might be the best idea I’ve ever had. As I said above, student writers are motivated by feedback that is individualized, relevant, and supportive. Using suggesticisms definitely improved that motivation. In addition, suggesticisms require those giving comments to move beyond merely recognizing what they don’t like in a piece of writing to articulating at least one better way of doing it. Student writers frequently end up with numerous ideas about how to revise a passage or some aspect of their writing. The added positivity was a plus for all concerned, and it was a kick to see how the new word became part of our classroom culture.

suggesticismIn general, peer review works best when students are fairly homogenous in ability. In a homogenous class, some of the social factors are mitigated when students see writing from other students that has common ground with their own writing. If a class isn’t particularly homogenous, peer review may not be the most effective revision activity for those students.

Empower writers to retain control of their work. Too often peer review sessions require writers to hand over control of their writing to others who may not have the compassion or competence to deal with it responsibly or respectfully. A brilliant colleague developed a technique based on the work of Peter Elbow which allows each writer to maintain control of his own work and decide what is discussed by his reviewers.

The student whose work is being considered develops a set of questions to guide reviewers, and reviewers respond only to those questions posed by the writer. Students are encouraged to create questions focused on specific issues and avoid mere mechanical concerns that can be cleaned up in later drafts. Here are examples of successful specific questions from my colleague Russ Anderson:

  • What do you think about the transition to 3rd person POV at the end of the story? Is it awkward?
  • What did you think about the leaf being able to notice things or being somewhat portrayed as having feelings like a human?
  • In the second to last paragraph, do you think my example about texting and driving is too off topic?
  • What do you think are the top 3 words used by teens today? Would you agree on the words I chose?
  • Do you think the two short stories connected well with the main idea of the first 3 paragraphs?
  • Did I maintain Holden’s voice throughout the story?
  • What difference would it make if I had names for the characters?

The responses to these kinds of questions generate thoughtful revisions, all while keeping the writer in control of his work.

If you experience frustration with peer editing sessions that are somewhere between unproductive and hostile, please know you’re not alone. The learning that is possible from this activity is valuable, but it can be difficult to bring to light because of the inherent social factors. I hope these suggesticisms are useful to you and your students.

Your comments and perspectives are always welcome here. Thank you for reading.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

2016: My Year in Books

2016-coversWarning: This post may be of no interest to anyone but myself. Here is my annual reflection on what I read in the past year, with a Top 16 for ’16, a list I may find myself disagreeing with by tomorrow.

2016 was a tumultuous year, no doubt about it, but it also brought me out-sized portions of inspiration, laughter, friendship, and optimism. The books I read were all a part of that.

To be honest, as I look back at the 197 books I read this year, I can’t even remember some of them. Others though keep reminding me of important truths and perspectives different from my own.

I read several books about music this year, especially rock and country music. That music has always been important to me, so when I have a chance to understand it better through a book, I usually jump on it. Bruce Springsteen is a heroic figure for me, and his 2016 autobiography Born to Run tells his story with courage, charm, and his unmistakable voice. One of the highlights of my year was meeting Bruce at an event in Chicago to publicize the book. If I had to pick one favorite book for 2016, Born to Run would be it.


I had the chance to meet and exchange a few words with Bruce Springsteen in Chicago on November 28, 2016.  I told him I thought his book was really good and that I hoped he had more books in him.  Bruce said, “Thanks,” and “God bless.”

My country underwent some strange political contortions in 2016, and I tried to gain some perspective on all that through reading. The most helpful were Hillbilly Elegy and The Presidents Club. Both books helped me understand some of the currents in this country that are working their ways to the surface and how the presidency interfaces with all of that.

I’m always on the search for appealing humor books. I don’t like humor that is overly crass, and I like when writers see things in quirky ways and tell about them in surprising language. The most satisfying humor writers for me this year were Carrie Fisher and Bill Bryson.

Throughout the year, and especially in late summer, I tried to keep up with the best picture books of the year. Almost a third of my favorite books of the year are picture books. I admire the inventive ways that writing and illustrating come together to spark the imaginations of the youngest readers.

After posting something like what you’re reading here—and thank you for sticking with this–I sometimes get comments or questions about how (and why) I read so much. Many others read much more than me, so I’m not a record-setter or anywhere close. In fact, I’m kind of a slow but persistent reader. With that in mind, here are five ways I read:

1. My phone is usually with me, and I always have something interesting loaded on the Kindle app. While standing in line at the post office on Saturday others were mildly seething, but I read seven or eight pages of a book. Finishing that book might take me weeks or months, but who cares.

2. I get daily emails about e-book deals. When a book that interests me pops up, I buy it, usually for just a couple of bucks. I take my Kindle when travelling, and those books are my airplane and hotel reading.

3. I almost always have an audiobook going in the car. I tend to like nonfiction for audiobooks.

4. I don’t watch much television. I’d rather read.

5. I read several books at the same time. My attention span is zilch, so I like to bounce around between books. I usually finish all of them eventually. If I were only reading one at a time, I would bounce between that one book and piddling around doing something besides reading.

Although some of these books were published earlier, here are my Top 16 for ’16 in no particular order:

1. Jennifer Niven: All the Bright Places
2. Allison Marchetti and Rebekah O’Dell: Writing with Mentors
3. Cammie McGovern: A Step Toward Falling
4. Elizabeth Gilbert: Big Magic
5. Pat Conroy: Beach Music
6. J. D. Vance: Hillbilly Elegy
7. Frederik Backman: A Man Called Ove
8. Jennifer Mason-Black: Devil and the Bluebird
9. Bruce Springsteen: Born to Run
10. Candace Fleming: Giant Squid
11. Jolene Thompson: Faraway Fox
12. Sierra DeMulder: Today Means Amen
13. Michael Duffy and Nancy Gibbs: The Presidents Club
14. Salina Yoon: Be a Friend
15. Sherman Alexie: Thunder Boy, Jr.
16. Brendan Wenzel: They All Saw a Cat

Here is the complete list of books I read in 2016 in roughly the order I finished them:

1. Mike Sewall: The Pitch That Killed
2. Cammie McGovern: A Step Toward Falling
3. Lindsay Mattick: Finding Winnie
4. Troy Andrews: Trombone Shorty
5. Liniers: Written and Drawn by Henrietta
6. Elizabeth Gilbert: Big Magic
7. Sarah Vowell: Lafayette in the Somewhat United States
8. Margarita Engle: Enchanted Air
9. Allison Marchetti and Rebekah O’Dell: Writing with Mentors
10. Stephen Savage: Supertruck
11. Stan Lee: Amazing Fantastic Incredible: A Marvel Memoir
12. A. E. Hotchner: The Good Life According to Hemingway
13. Stephen King: The Bazaar of Bad Dreams
14. Ramin Gameshram: A Birthday Cake for George Washington
15. Rachel Isadora: I Hear a Pickle
16. Salina Yoon: Be A Friend
17. Kelly Starling Lyons: Ellen’s Broom
18. Steve Sheinkin: Most Dangerous
19. Bob Woodward: The Last of the President’s Men
20. Bill Bryson: One Summer: America, 1927
21. Ryan T. Higgins: Mother Bruce
22. Birgitta Sif: Where My Feet Go
23. Jason Reynolds and Brendan Kiely: All American Boys
24. Anthony Doerr: Four Seasons in Rome
25. Sierra DeMulder: Today Means Amen
26. David Denby: Lit Up
27. Rick Bragg: My Southern Journey
28. Randy Wayne White: The Sharks of Lake Nicaragua
29. Peter H. Reynolds: Going Places
30. Nikki Grimes: Poems in the Attic
31. Kelly DiPucchio: Gaston
32. Trudy Ludwig: The Invisible Boy
33. Chris Butterworth: How Did That Get In My Lunchbox: The Story of Food
34. Suzanne Lang: Families, Families, Families
35. Kathryn Gibbs Davis: Mr. Ferris and His Wheel
36. Andrea Beaty: Rosie Revere, Engineer
37. Lynne Cox: Elizabeth, Queen of the Seas
38. Kathy Parks: The Lifeboat Clique
39. Vaunda Micheaux Nelson: The Book Itch: Freedom, Truth, & Harlem’s Greatest Bookstore
40. Amy Cuddy: Presence
41. Miranda Paul: One Plastic Bag: Isatou Ceesay and the Recycling Women of the Gambia
42. Susan Lynn Meyer: New Shoes
43. Danah Boyd: It’s Complicated: The Social Lives of Networked Teens
44. Pat Conroy: The Great Santini
45. William Shatner: Leonard: My Fifty-Year Friendship with a Remarkable Man
46. Audrey Vernick: The Kid from Diamond Street
47. Rick Steves: Travel as a Political Act
48. Hervé Tullet: Let’s Play
49. Carrie Fisher: Wishful Drinking
50. John Brandon: Citrus County
51. Kwame Alexander: Booked
52. Robert Burleigh and Wendell Minor: Trapped!: A Whale’s Rescue
53. Irin Karmon and Shana Knizhnik: Notorious RBG: The Life and Times of Ruth Bader Ginsburg
54. Randy Wayne White: Deep Blue
55. Mark Holtzen: A Ticket to the Pennant: A Tale of Baseball in Seattle
56. Jennifer Niven: All the Bright Places
57. Jess Keating: Pink is for Blobfish
58. Jane Smiley: Twenty Yawns
59. Ken Mochizuki: Baseball Saved Us
60. Kathryn Lasky: Georgia Rises
61. Nancy Churnin: The William Hoy Story: How a Deaf Baseball Player Changed the Game
62. Julie Murphy: Dumplin’
63. Lisa Brown: The Airport Book
64. Thomas Newkirk: The Art of Slow Reading
65. Sherman Alexie: Thunder Boy Jr.
66. Benjamin Alire Sáenz: Aristotle and Dante Discover the Secrets of the Universe
67. Eric Weiner: The Geography of Genius
68. Mark Pett: The Girl Who Never Made Mistakes
69. Chris Bachelder: The Throwback Special
70. Lisa Mantchev: Strictly No Elephants
71. Andrew Smith:100 Sideways Miles
72. Michelle Markel: Hillary Rodham Clinton: Some Girls Are Born to Lead
73. David Hajdu: Positively 4th Street
74. Tara Sullivan: The Bitter Side of Sweet
75. Terry Jennings: Waylon: Tales of My Outlaw Dad
76. Barb Rosenstock: Dorothea’s Eyes
77. Pat Conroy: Beach Music
78. Milan Kundera: The Festival of Insignificance
79. Paula Hawkins: The Girl on the Train
80. Julie Falatko: Snappsy the Alligator (Did Not Ask to Be in This Book)
81. Don Brown: Aaron and Alexander
82. Nancy Gibbs and Michael Duffy: The Presidents Club
83. Lauren Roedy Vaughn: OCD, The Dude, and Me
84. Ted Kooser: The Bell in the Bridge
85. Pat Conroy: The Death of Santini
86. Bruce Bohrer: The Best Seat in the House
87. Amy Krouse Rosenthal: Textbook Amy Krouse Rosenthal
88. Jo Knowles: Still A Work in Progress
89. Neal Shusterman: Unwind
90. Adam Rex: School’s First Day of School
91. Elanna Allen: Poor Little Guy
92. Jon Agee: Lion Lessons
93. Hannah E. Harrison: My Friend Maggie!
94. Maria Gianferrari: Coyote Moon
95. Hudson Talbott: From Wolf to Woof!
96. Giselle Potter: This Is My Dollhouse
97. Bill Slavin: Who Broke the Teapot?!
98. Lori Haskins Houran: Next to You: A Book of Adorableness
99. Anne Hunter: Cricket Song
100. Diana Murray: City Shapes
101. Cale Atkinson: Explorers of the Wild
102. Aaron Becker: Return
103. Dave Keane: Who Wants a Tortoise?
104. Akiko Miyakoshi: The Storm
105. David Litchfield: The Bear and the Piano
106. Stacy McAnulty: Excellent Ed
107. K. G. Campbell: Dylan the Villain
108. Matty Long: Super Happy Magic Forest
109. Daniel Bernstrom: One Day in the Eucalyptus, Eucalyptus Tree
110. David Barrow: Have You Seen Elephant?
111. Evan Turk: The Storyteller
112. Adam Lehrhaupt: Chicken in Space
113. Kyle Mewburn: Hill & Hole
114. Alex T. Smith: Little Red and the Very Hungry Lion
115. Shane Peacock: The Artist and Me
116. Ame Dyckman: Horrible Bear!
117. J. J. Austrian: Worm Loves Worm
118. Mark Sommerset: Baa Baa Smart Sheep
119. Dan Santat: Are We There Yet?
120. Mo Willems: The Thank You Book
121. Philip C. Stead: Ideas Are All Around
122. Jeanne Birdsall: My Favorite Pets
123. Eugenie Doyle: Sleep Tight Farm
124. Katrina Goldsaito: The Sound of Silence
125. Antoinette Portis: Best Frints in the Whole Universe
126. Minh Le: Let Me Finish!
127. Mahak Jain: Maya
128. F. Isabel Campoy: Maybe Something Beautiful
129. Steve Goetz: Old MacDonald Had a Truck
130. Bob Boilen: Your Song Changed My Life
130. Erin Hagar: The Inventor of Lego Toys
131. Torben Kuhlmann: Armstrong: Mouse on the Moon
132. Dan Richards: Can One Balloon Make an Elephant Fly?
133. Patrick Downes: Come Home, Angus
134. Lucy Ruth Cummins: A Hungry Lion, or a Dwindling Assortment of Animals
135. Brendan Wenzel: They All Saw a Cat
136. Sean Ferrell: The Snurtch
137. Rebecca Kai Dotlich: The Knowing Book
138. Pat Conroy: The Pat Conroy Cookbook
139. Bill Bryson: Neither Here nor There
140. Ron Fournier: Love That Boy
141. Andrew Smith: Winger
142. Susan Verde: The Water Princess
143. Jolene Thompson: Faraway Fox
144. Kate Beaton: King Baby
145. Heidi Schulz: Giraffes Ruin Everything
146. Benedikt Groß: ABC: The Alphabet from the Sky
147. Mac Barnett: How This Book Was Made
148. Jim LaMarche: Pond
149. Cynthia Rylant: Creation
150. Oliver Jeffers: A Child of Books
151. Vera Brosgol: Leave Me Alone
152. Bryan Stevenson: Just Mercy
153. Raina Telgemeier: Ghosts
154. Mary Roach: Grunt
155. Lauren Stringer: Yellow Time
156. Debbie Levy: I Dissent: Ruth Bader Ginsburg Makes Her Mark
157. Drew Dernavich: It’s Not Easy Being Number Three
158. Gae Polisner: The Memory of Things
159. J. D. Vance: Hillbilly Elegy
160. Candace Fleming: Giant Squid
161. Philip C. Stead: Samson in the Snow
162. Jason Carter Eaton: How to Track a Truck
163. Norman Messenger: An Artist’s Alphabet
164. Maribeth Boelts: A Bike Like Sergio’s
165. Jory John: Penguin Problems
166. Deana Martin: Memories Are Made of This
167. Jon Klassen: We Found a Hat
168. Kelly DiPucchio: Dragon Was Terrible
169. Joyce Sidman: Before Morning
170. Kate DiCamillo: Raymie Nightingale
171. Bruce Springsteen: Born to Run
172. Kurt Cyrus: Billions of Bricks
173. James Howe: Big Bob, Little Bob
174. Bill Clinton: Giving
175. Garrison Keillor: The Old Man Who Loved Cheese
176. Dave Barry: Best. State. Ever.
177. Demi: The Shady Tree
178. Katie Kennedy: Learning to Swear in America
179. Kaitlin Ward: Bleeding Earth
180. Tommy Wallach: Thanks for the Trouble
181. Randy Wayne White: Seduced
182. Candice Millard: Destiny of the Republic
183. Peter Mills: The Monkees, Head, and the 60s
184. Elizabeth Briggs: Future Shock
185. Carson Ellis: Du Iz Tak?
186. Jennifer Mason-Black: Devil and the Bluebird
187. Michael Tackett: The Baseball Whisperer
188. David Hepworth: Never A Dull Moment: 1971–The Year Rock Exploded
189. Garrison Keillor, Editor: Good Poems
190. Barbara McClintock: Lost and Found: Adele and Simon in China
191. A. S. King: Still Life with Tornado
192. Anna Kendrick: Scrappy Little Nobody
193. Pat Conroy: The Lords of Discipline
194. Robison Wells: Dark Energy
195. John Lewis: March Book Three
196. Fredrik Backman: A Man Called Ove
197. Carrie Fisher: The Princess Diarist

My first reading goal for 2017 is to finish Ron Chernow’s Alexander Hamilton.  And a tempting book club invitation came my way today.  It never ends.

I wish you a happy reading year in 2017!

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

Review: NEVER A DULL MOMENT: 1971 by David Hepworth

David Hepworth’s Never A Dull Moment: 1971 claims that 1971 was the most important year in rock history. While many fans are sentimental about specific years or time spans, Hepworth makes the case that no other year has produced so much influential, memorable music or generated so many currents that rippled through what came after.

1971Let’s begin with a list of some of the albums released in 1971:
Carole King: Tapestry
The Allman Brothers Band: At Fillmore East
Marvin Gaye: What’s Going On
The Rolling Stones: Sticky Fingers
Led Zeppelin: IV
Jethro Tull: Aqualung
Carly Simon: Carly Simon and Anticipation
The Who: Who’s Next
John Prine: John Prine
The Beach Boys: Surf’s Up
Nitty Gritty Dirt Band: Will the Circle Be Unbroken
Black Sabbath: Masters of Reality
Nilsson: Nilsson Schmilson
The Doors: L. A. Woman
Isaac Hayes: Shaft
Van Morrison: Tupelo Honey

On that list are some of the best-selling albums of all time, including work that influenced what would become blues-rock, heavy metal, country-rock, and folk-rock. Some of these albums are from established bands; others are by newcomers. And it’s just the beginning.

Here are some songs released in 1971 that have stood the test of time, although they were not on albums as distinguished as those above. (Get ready to hum.)
Neil Diamond: “I Am … I Said”
Elton John: “Tiny Dancer”
Jackson Browne: “Doctor My Eyes”
America: “Ventura Highway”
John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band: “Power to the People”
John Lennon: “Imagine”
Don McLean: “American Pie”
Yes: “Roundabout”
Badfinger: “Baby Blue” and “Day After Day”
Rod Stewart: “Maggie May”
Al Green: “Tired of Being Alone”
Janis Joplin: “Me and Bobby McGee”
Ringo Starr: “It Don’t Come Easy”
Paul and Linda McCartney: “Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey”
James Taylor: “You’ve Got a Friend”
Bill Withers: “Ain’t No Sunshine”
The Jackson 5: “Never Can Say Goodbye”
Sly and The Family Stone: “Family Affair”
Stevie Wonder: “If You Really Love Me”

Whew. Those albums and those songs seem like they should be a decade’s worth of music, but they all arrived in 1971.

Never A Dull Moment: 1971 isn’t a book of lists. It’s a book of stories. The stories and personalities blend to create a vivid picture of that year in music. Hepworth takes us through 1971 month by month, telling about the most important recordings and happenings from each flip of the calendar. By examining in more detail some of what was going on, we see the recordings in a context as rich as the individual records. For example, Motown was changed forever by the 1971 work of Stevie Wonder and Marvin Gaye. Then the first big rock concert staged for a cause was George Harrison’s Concert for Bangladesh with Bob Dylan, Ringo Starr, Eric Clapton, Badfinger, and Leon Russell. Rock journalism also took a big step forward as something separate from entertainment journalism with Rolling Stone‘s “The Beach Boys: A California Saga” cover story about the darker side of the band. Mick Jagger got married in a frenzy, and Stevie Wonder was introduced to new musical technology. All of these events wrap around the music to provide insights into the culture on both sides of the Atlantic. Any discussion of rock music in 1971 requires a balanced view of the British and American scenes, and Hepworth handles that masterfully without any obvious bias toward one side of the Atlantic or the other.

Some of the smaller moments are the most memorable, including juicy bits such as Cat Stevens introducing his then-girlfriend Carly Simon to her future husband James Taylor, and John Prine’s first record deal growing out of a serendipitous late-night prowl with … Paul Anka.

1971 was also the beginning of what Hepworth calls “heritage rock” as the first generation of rock stars attempted to figure out how to look forward and backward at the same time. 1971 was the first post-Beatles year. George and Ringo did the Bangladesh concert while John and Yoko did their thing, and Paul and Linda did theirs. The Rolling Stones were re-tooling but created Sticky Fingers, their first record conceived as an album rather than as a song collection. The Beach Boys had their distinctive sound but wanted to move beyond songs about girls, cars, and surfing with Brian Wilson largely sidelined by mental problems. Bob Dylan reunited with The Band. And Elvis Presley went on tour for the first time in almost fourteen years.

In addition to the rock veterans, some newcomers were making impressive stirrings: Kraftwerk, The Eagles, Roxy Music. 1971 also saw the emergence of Alice Cooper, Cat Stevens, David Bowie, and Rod Stewart. Think about it. That’s an amazingly diverse group of artists to be surfacing at the same time.

Never A Dull Moment: 1971 is an absorbing, fascinating, thoroughly satisfying romp through twelve months of glorious music, dynamic personalities, and raucous goings-on.

I can recommend the audiobook version of Never A Dull Moment: 1971 narrated by Hepworth himself. His British accent with a touch of the Liverpudlian is charming and energetic. Hepworth never seems to be reading as he enthusiastically tells the tales of this remarkable year.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

Review: DEVIL AND THE BLUEBIRD by Jennifer Mason-Black

Devil and the BluebirdBluesman Robert Johnson wasn’t the only musician to go down to the crossroads and make a deal with the devil. In Jennifer Mason-Black’s Devil and the Bluebird, 17-year-old Blue Riley takes her guitar and meets up with the red-haired woman in the red dress. Blue promises her soul for a chance to find her missing sister.

This sets Blue on a journey across America, alone, where she discovers the darkness awaiting young people living on their own, homeless and without means. She learns about human traffickers, shelters for abused women and children, families who reject transgender children, and those twisted individuals who simply enjoy harming others. Through all the ghosts and demons, Blue’s guitar and her musical instincts give her insights into when and who to trust.

The strengths of Devil and the Bluebird include a countdown aspect that drives the narrative hard, and the edgy twang of Mason-Black’s narrative voice. Some of her characters are unforgettably evil, while others are sympathetic as they struggle to decide what to risk and whether to be generous. Although this book is marketed as YA, it defies and transcends that categorization.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment